2: Dental Caries: Etiology, Clinical Characteristics, Risk Assessment, and Management

Dental Caries

Etiology, Clinical Characteristics, Risk Assessment, and Management

André V. Ritter, R. Scott Eidson and Terence E. Donovan

This chapter presents basic definitions and information on dental caries, clinical characteristics of the caries lesion, caries risk assessment, and caries management, in the context of clinical operative dentistry.

What is Dental Caries?

Dental caries is a multifactorial, transmissible, infectious oral disease caused primarily by the complex interaction of cariogenic oral flora (biofilm) with fermentable dietary carbohydrates on the tooth surface over time. Traditionally, this tooth-biofilm-carbohydrate interaction has been illustrated by the classical Keyes-Jordan diagram (Fig. 2-1).1 However, dental caries onset and activity are, in fact, much more complex than this three-way interaction, as not all persons with teeth, biofilm, and consuming carbohydrates will have caries over time. Several modifying risk and protective factors influence the dental caries process, as will be discussed later in this chapter.

At the tooth level, caries activity is characterized by localized demineralization and loss of tooth structure (Figs. 2-2 and 2-3). Cariogenic bacteria in the biofilm metabolize refined carbohydrates for energy and produce organic acid by-products. These organic acids, if present in the biofilm ecosystem for extended periods, can lower the pH in the biofilm to below a critical level (5.5 for enamel, 6.2 for dentin). The low pH drives calcium and phosphate from the tooth to the biofilm in an attempt to reach equilibrium, hence resulting in a net loss of minerals by the tooth, or demineralization. When the pH in the biofilm returns to neutral and the concentration of soluble calcium and phosphate is supersaturated relative to that in the tooth, mineral can then be added back to partially demineralized enamel, in a process called remineralization. At the tooth surface and sub-surface level, therefore, dental caries results from a dynamic process of attack (demineralization) and restitution (remineralization) of the tooth matter. These events take place several times a day over the life of the tooth and are modulated by many factors, including number and type of microbial flora in the biofilm, diet, oral hygiene, genetics, dental anatomy, use of fluorides and other chemotherapeutic agents, salivary flow and buffering capacity; and inherent resistance of the tooth structure and composition that will differ from person to person, tooth to tooth, and site to site. The balance between demineralization and remineralization has been illustrated in terms of pathologic factors (i.e., those favoring demineralization) and protective factors (i.e., those favoring remineralization) (Fig. 2-4).2 Individuals in whom the balance tilts predominantly toward protective factors (remineralization) are much less likely to develop dental caries than those in which the balance is tilted toward pathologic factors (demineralization). Understanding the balance between demineralization and remineralization is key to caries management.

Fig. 2-3 Extensive active caries in a young adult (same patient as in Fig. 2-2). A, Mirror view of teeth No. 20-22. B, Cavitated lesions (a) are surrounded by extensive areas of chalky, opaque demineralized areas (b). The presence of smooth-surface lesions such as these is associated with rampant caries. Occlusal and interproximal smooth-surface caries usually occur in advance of facial smooth-surface lesions. The presence of these types of lesions should alert the dentist to the possibility of extensive caries activity elsewhere in the mouth. The interproximal gingiva is swollen red and would bleed easily on probing. These gingival changes are the consequence of long-standing irritation from the plaque adherent to the teeth.

Repeated demineralization events may result from a predominantly pathologic environment causing the localized dissolution and destruction of the calcified dental tissues, evidenced as a caries lesion or a “cavity.” Severe demineralization of enamel results in the formation of a cavitation in the enamel surface. Severe demineralization of dentin results in the exposure of the protein matrix, which is denatured initially by host matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and is subsequently degraded by MMPs and other bacterial proteases. Demineralization of the inorganic phase and denaturation and degradation of the organic phase result in dentin cavitation.3

It is essential to understand that caries lesions, or cavitations in teeth, are signs of an underlying condition, an imbalance between protective and pathologic factors favoring the latter. In clinical practice, it is very easy to lose sight of this fact and focus entirely on the restorative treatment of caries lesions, failing to treat the underlying cause of the disease (Table 2-1). Although symptomatic treatment is important, failure to identify and treat the underlying causative factors allows the disease to continue. This chapter emphasizes the components of a caries management program that is based first on risk assessment and then on modifying the biofilm ecology to enhance protective factors and minimize pathologic factors.4

Table 2-1

Caries Management Based on the Medical Model

Primary Etiology Cariogenic Biofilm (Infection)
Symptoms Demineralization lesions in teeth
Treatment, symptomatic Restoration of cavitated lesions
Treatment, therapeutic Improvement of host resistance by (1) biofilm control, (2) elevating biofilm pH, and (3) enhancing remineralization
Post-treatment assessment, symptomatic Examination of teeth for new lesions
Post-treatment assessment, therapeutic Re-evaluation of etiologic conditions and primary and secondary risk factors; and continuous management based on findings

This chapter also presents information on clinical characteristics of caries lesion as they relate to clinical operative dentistry. Use of correct and consistent terms when referring to caries lesions is important. Box 2-1 summarizes the most common terms used in this textbook to define caries lesions based on their location, cavitation status, and activity status.

Box 2.1   Caries Lesion Definitions

This box summarizes the most common terms used in this textbook to define caries lesions based on their location, cavitation status, and activity status.

image Caries lesion. Tooth demineralization as a result of the caries process. Other texts may use the term carious lesion. Laypeople may use the term cavity.

image Smooth-surface caries. A caries lesion on a smooth tooth surface.

image Pit-and-fissure caries. A caries lesion on a pit-and-fissure area.

image Occlusal caries. A caries lesion on an occlusal surface.

image Proximal caries. A caries lesion on a proximal surface.

image Enamel caries. A caries lesion in enamel, typically indicating that the lesion has not penetrated into dentin. (Note that many lesions detected clinically as enamel caries may very well have extended into dentin histologically.)

image Dentin caries. A caries lesion into dentin.

image Coronal caries. A caries lesion in any surface of the anatomic tooth crown.

image Root caries. A caries lesion in the root surface.

image Primary caries. A caries lesion not adjacent to an existing restoration or crown.

image Secondary caries. A caries lesion adjacent to an existing restoration, crown, or sealant. Other term used is caries adjacent to restorations and sealants (CARS). Also referred to as recurrent caries, implying that a primary caries lesion was restored but that the lesion reoccurred.

image Residual caries. Refers to carious tissue that was not completely excavated prior to placing a restoration. Sometimes residual caries can be difficult to differentiate from secondary caries.

image Cavitated caries lesion. A caries lesion that results in the breaking of the integrity of the tooth, or a cavitation.

image Non-cavitated caries lesion. A caries lesion that has not been cavitated. In enamel caries, non-cavitated lesions are also referred to as “white spot” lesions.

    (Clinically, the distinction between a cavitated and a noncavitated caries lesion is not as simple as it may seem. Although historically any roughness detectable with a sharp explorer has been considered a cavitated lesion, more recent caries detection guidelines establish that only lesions in which a blunt probe (e.g., WHO[World Health Organization]/CPI[Communty Periodonatal Index]/PSR[Periodontal Screening and Recording] probe) penetrates are to be considered cavitated. This distinction has important implications on lesion management.)

image Active caries lesion. A caries lesion that is considered to be biologically active, that is, lesion in which tooth demineralization is in frank activity at the time of examination.

image Inactive caries lesion. A caries lesion that is considered to be biologically inactive at the time of examination, that is, in which tooth demineralization caused by caries may have happened in the past but has stopped and is currently stalled. Also referred to as arrested caries, meaning that the caries process has been arrested but that the clinical signs of the lesion itself are still present.

image Rampant caries. Term used to describe the presence of extensive and multiple cavitated and active caries lesions in the same person. Typically used in association with “baby bottle caries,” “radiation therapy caries,” or “meth-mouth caries.” These terms refer to the etiology of the condition.

Ecologic Basis of Dental Caries: The Role of the Biofilm

Dental plaque is a term historically used to describe the soft, tenacious film accumulating on the surface of teeth. Dental plaque has been more recently referred to as a plaque biofilm, or simply biofilm, which is a more complete and accurate description of its composition (bio) and structure (film).5 Biofilm is composed mostly of bacteria, their by-products, extracellular matrix, and water (Figs. 2-5 to 2-9). Biofilm is not adherent food debris, as is widely and erroneously thought, nor does it result from the haphazard collection of opportunistic microorganisms. The accumulation of biofilm on teeth is a highly organized and ordered sequence of events. Many of the organisms found in the mouth are not found elsewhere in nature. Survival of microorganisms in the oral environment depends on their ability to adhere to a surface. Free-floating organisms are cleared rapidly from the mouth by salivary flow and frequent swallowing. Only a few specialized organisms, primarily streptococci, are able to adhere to oral surfaces such as the mucosa and tooth structure.

Fig. 2-5 A, Composite diagram illustrating the relationship of plaque biofilm (p) to the enamel in a smooth-surface noncavitated lesion. A relatively cell-free layer of precipitated salivary protein material, the acquired pellicle (ap), covers the perikymata ridges (pr). The plaque bacteria attach to the pellicle. Overlapping perikymata ridges can be seen on surface of enamel (see Fig. 2-6). Figs. 2-7 to 2-9 are photomicrographs of cross-sections of plaque biofilm. The enamel is composed of rod-like structures (er) that course from the inner dentinoenamel junction (DEJ) to the surface of the crown. Striae of Retzius (sr) can be seen in cross-sections of enamel. B, Higher power view of the cutout portion of enamel in A. Enamel rods interlock with each other in a head-to-tail orientation. The rod heads are visible on the surface as slight depressions on the perikymata ridges. The enamel rods comprise tightly packed crystallites. The orientation of the crystallites changes from being parallel to the rod in the head region to being perpendicular to the rod axis in the tail end. Striae of Retzius form a descending diagonal line, descending cervically. C, Drawings 1 through 5 illustrate the various stages in colonization during plaque formation on the shaded enamel block shown in B. The accumulated mass of bacteria on the tooth surface may become so thick that it is visible to the unaided eye. Such plaques are gelatinous and tenaciously adherent; they readily take up disclosing dyes, aiding in their visualization for oral hygiene instruction. Thick plaque biofilms (4 and 5) are capable of great metabolic activity when sufficient nutrients are available. The gelatinous nature of the plaque limits outward diffusion of metabolic products and serves to prolong the retention of organic acid metabolic byproducts.

Significant differences exist in the biofilm communities found in various habitats (ecologic environments) within the oral cavity (Fig. 2-10). Teeth normally have a biofilm community dominated by Streptococcus sanguis and S. mitis. The population size of mutans streptococci (MS) on teeth varies. Normally, it is a small percentage of the total biofilm population, but it can be one-half the facultative streptococcal flora in other biofilms. Mature plaque biofilm communities have tremendous metabolic potential and are capable of rapid anaerobic metabolism of any available carbohydrates (Fig. 2-11).

Fig. 2-11 A, Mature plaque biofilm communities have tremendous metabolic potential and are capable of rapid anaerobic metabolism of any available carbohydrates. Classic studies by Stephan show this metabolic potential by severe pH drops at the plaque-enamel interface after glucose rinse. It is generally agreed that a pH of 5.5 is the threshold for enamel demineralization. Exposure to a glucose rinse for an extreme caries activity plaque results in a sustained period of demineralization (pH 5.5). Recording from a slight caries activity plaque shows a much shorter period of demineralization. B, The frequency of sucrose exposure for cariogenic plaque greatly influences the progress of tooth demineralization. The top line illustrates pH depression, patterned after Stephan’s curves in A. Three meals per day results in three exposures of plaque acids, each lasting approximately 1 hour. The plaque pH depression is relatively independent of the quantity of sucrose ingested. Between-meal snacks or the use of sweetened breath mints results in many more acid attacks, as illustrated at the bottom. The effect of frequent ingestion of small quantities of sucrose results in a nearly continuous acid attack on the tooth surface. The clinical consequences of this behavior can be seen in Fig. 2-35. C, In active caries, a progressive loss of mineral content subjacent to the cariogenic plaque occurs. Inset illustrates that the loss is not a continuous process. Instead, alternating periods of mineral loss (demineralization) occur, with intervening periods of remineralization. The critical event for the tooth is cavitation of the surface, marked by the vertical dashed line. This event marks an acceleration in caries destruction of the tooth and irreversible loss of tooth structure. For these reasons, restorative intervention is required. (A, adapted and redrawn from Stephan RM: Intra-oral hydrogen-ion concentration associated with dental caries activity, J Dent Res 23:257, 1944.)

Many distinct habitats may be identified on individual teeth, with each habitat containing a unique biofilm community (Table 2-2). Although the pits and fissures on the crown may harbor a relatively simple population of streptococci, the root surface in the gingival sulcus may harbor a complex community dominated by filamentous and spiral bacteria. Facial and lingual smooth surfaces and proximal surfaces also may harbor vastly different biofilm communities. The mesial surface of a molar may be carious and have a biofilm dominated by large populations of MS and lactobacilli, whereas the distal surface may lack these organisms and be caries-free. Generalization about biofilm communities is difficult. Nevertheless, the general activity of biofilm growth and maturation is predictable and sufficiently well known to be of therapeutic importance in the prevention of caries.

Table 2-2

Oral Habitats*

Habitat Predominant Species Environmental Conditions within Plaque
Mucosa S. mitis Aerobic
  S. sanguis pH approximately 7
  S. salivarius Oxidation-reduction potential positive
Tongue S. salivarius Aerobic
  S. mutans pH approximately 7
  S. sanguis Oxidation-reduction potential positive
Teeth (non-carious) S. sanguis Aerobic
  pH 5.5
  Oxidation-reduction negative
Gingival crevice Fusobacterium Anaerobic
Spirochaeta pH variable
Actinomyces Oxidation-reduction very negative
Enamel caries S. mutans Anaerobic
  pH <5.5
  Oxidation-reduction negative
Dentin caries S. mutans Anaerobic
Lactobacillus pH <5.5
  Oxidation-reduction negative
Root caries Actinomyces Anaerobic
    pH <5.5
    Oxidation-reduction negative


*The micro-environmental conditions in the habitats associated with host health are generally aerobic, near neutrality in pH, and positive in oxidation-reduction potential. Significant micro-environmental changes are associated with caries and periodontal disease. The changes are the result of the plaque community metabolism.

Professional tooth cleaning is intended to control biofilm (plaque) and prevent disease. After professional removal of all organic material and bacteria from the tooth surface, a new coating of organic material begins to accumulate immediately. Within 2 hours, a cell-free, structureless organic film, the acquired enamel pellicle (AEP, see Figs. 2-5, A and C), can cover the previously denuded area completely. The pellicle is formed primarily from the selective precipitation of various components of saliva. The functions of the pellicle are believed to be as follows: (1) to protect the enamel, (2) to reduce friction between teeth, and (3) possibly to provide a matrix for remineralization.6

Tooth Habitats for Cariogenic Biofilm

The tooth surface is unique because it is not protected by the surface shedding mechanisms (continual replacement of epithelial cells) used throughout the remainder of the alimentary canal. The tooth surface is stable and covered with the pellicle of precipitated salivary glycoproteins, enzymes, and immunoglobulins. It is the ideal surface for the attachment of many oral streptococci. If left undisturbed, biofilm rapidly builds up to sufficient depth to produce an anaerobic environment adjacent to the tooth surface. Tooth habitats favorable for harboring pathogenic biofilm include (1) pits and fissures (Fig. 2-12); (2) the smooth enamel surfaces immediately gingival to the proximal contacts and in the gingival third of the facial and lingual surfaces of the clinical crown (Fig. 2-13); (3) root surfaces, particularly near the cervical line; and (4) subgingival areas (Fig. 2-14). These sites correspond to the locations where caries lesions are most frequently found.

Fig. 2-14 A, Caries may originate at many distinct sites: pits and fissures (a), smooth surface of crown (b), and root surface (c). Proximal surface lesion of crown is not illustrated here because it is a special case of smooth-surface lesion. Histopathology and progress of facial (or lingual) and proximal lesions are identical. Dotted line indicates cut used to reveal cross-sections illustrated in B and C. B, In cross-section, the three types of lesions show different rates of progression and different morphology. Lesions illustrated here are intended to be representative of each type. No particular association between three lesions is implied. Pit-and-fissure lesions have small sites of origin visible on the occlusal surface but have a wide base. Overall shape of a pit-and-fissure lesion is an inverted “V.” In contrast, a smooth-surface lesion is V-shaped with a wide area of origin and apex of the V directed toward pulp (p). Root caries begins directly on dentin. Root-surface lesions can progress rapidly because dentin is less resistant to caries attack. C, Advanced caries lesions produce considerable histologic change in enamel, dentin, and pulp. Bacterial invasion of lesion results in extensive demineralization and proteolysis of the dentin. Clinically, this necrotic dentin appears soft, wet, and mushy. Deeper pulpally, dentin is demineralized, but not invaded by bacteria, and is structurally intact. This tissue appears to be dry and leathery in texture. Two types of pulp–dentin response are illustrated. Under pit-and-fissure lesions and smooth-surface lesions, odontoblasts have died, leaving empty tubules called dead tracts (dt). New odontoblasts have been differentiated from pulp mesenchymal cells. These new odontoblasts have produced reparative dentin (rd), which seals off dead tracts. Another type of pulp-dentin reaction is sclerosis (s)—occlusion of the tubules by peritubular dentin. This is illustrated under root-caries lesion.

Pits and Fissures

Pits and fissures are particularly susceptible surfaces for caries initiation (see Fig. 2-12; Figs. 2-15 to 2-19; see also Fig. 2-12). The pits and fissures provide excellent mechanical shelter for organisms and harbor a community dominated by S. sanguis and other streptococci.7 The relative proportion of MS most probably determines the cariogenic potential of the pit-and-fissure community. The appearance of MS in pits and fissures is usually followed by caries 6 to 24 months later. In susceptible patients, sealing the pits and fissures just after tooth eruption may be the most important event in their resistance to caries.

Fig. 2-16 A, Mandibular first molar has undermined discolored enamel owing to extensive pit-and-fissure caries. The lesion began as illustrated in Fig. 2-15 and has progressed to the stage illustrated in Fig. 2-15, D. B, Discolored enamel is outlined by broken line in the central fossa region.

Smooth Enamel Surfaces

The proximal enamel surfaces immediately gingival to the contact area are the second most susceptible areas to caries (Figs. 2-20 and 2-21; see also Figs. 2-14 and 2-18). These areas are protected physically and are relatively free from the effects of mastication, tongue movement, and salivary flow. The types and numbers of organisms composing the proximal surface biofilm community vary. Important ecologic determinants for the biofilm community on the proximal surfaces are the topography of the tooth surface, the size and shape of the gingival papillae, and the oral hygiene of the patient. A rough surface (caused by caries, a poor-quality restoration, or a structural defect) restricts adequate biofilm removal. This situation favors the occurrence of caries or periodontal disease at the site.

Fig. 2-21 Longitudinal sections (see inset for A) showing initiation and progression of caries on interproximal surfaces. A, Initial demineralization (indicated by the shading in the enamel) on the proximal surfaces is not detectable clinically or radiographically. All proximal surfaces are demineralized to some degree, but most are remineralized and become immune to further attack. The presence of small amounts of fluoride in the saliva virtually ensures that remineralization and immunity to further attack will occur. B, When proximal caries first becomes detectable radiographically, the enamel surface is likely still to be intact. An intact surface is essential for successful remineralization and arrest of the lesion. Demineralization of the dentin (indicated by the shading in the dentin) occurs before cavitation of the surface of the enamel. Treatment designed to promote remineralization can be effective up to this stage. C, Cavitation of the enamel surface is a critical event in the caries process in proximal surfaces. Cavitation is an irreversible process and requires restorative treatment and correction of the damaged tooth surface. Cavitation can be diagnosed only by clinical observation. The use of a sharp explorer to detect cavitation is problematic because excessive force in application of the explorer tip during inspection of the proximal surfaces can damage weakened enamel and accelerate the caries process by creating cavitation. Separation of the teeth can be used to provide more direct visual inspection of suspect surfaces. Fiberoptic illumination and dye absorption also are promising new evaluation procedures, but neither is specific for cavitation. D, Advanced cavitated lesions require prompt restorative intervention to prevent pulpal disease, limit tooth structure loss, and remove the nidus of infection of odontopathic organisms.

Root Surfaces

The proximal root surface, particularly near the cementoenamel junction (CEJ), often is unaffected by the action of hygiene procedures such as flossing because it may have concave anatomic surface contours (fluting) and occasional roughness at the termination of the enamel. These conditions, when coupled with exposure to the oral environment (as a result of gingival recession), favor the formation of mature, cariogenic biofilm and proximal root-surface caries. Likewise, the facial or lingual root surfaces (particularly near the CEJ), when exposed to the oral environment (because of gingival recession), are often both neglected in hygiene procedures and usually not rubbed by the bolus of food. Consequently, these root surfaces also frequently harbor cariogenic biofilm. Root-surface caries is more common in older patients because of niche availability and other factors sometimes associated with senescence, such as decreased salivary flow and poor oral hygiene as a result of lowered digital dexterity and decreased motivation. Caries originating on the root is alarming because (1) it has a comparatively rapid progression, (2) it is often asymptomatic, (3) it is closer to the pulp, and (4) it is more difficult to restore.

Oral Hygiene and Its Role in the Caries Process

Oral hygiene, accomplished primarily by proper tooth brushing and flossing, is another ecologic determinant of caries onset and activity. Careful mechanical cleaning of teeth disrupts the biofilm and leaves a clean enamel surface. The cleaning process does not destroy most of the oral bacteria but merely removes them from the surfaces of teeth. Large numbers of these bacteria subsequently are removed from the oral cavity during rinsing and swallowing after flossing and brushing, but sufficient numbers remain to recolonize teeth. Some fastidious organisms and obligate anaerobes may be killed by exposure to oxygen during tooth cleaning. No single species is likely to be entirely eliminated, however. Although all the species that compose mature biofilm continue to be present, most of these are unable to initiate colonization on the clean tooth surface.

Saliva: Nature’s Anticaries Agent

Saliva is an extremely important substance for the proper digestion of foods, and it also plays a key role as a natural anticaries agent (Table 2-3). Many medications are capable of reducing salivary flow and increasing caries risk (Table 2-4). The importance of saliva in the maintenance of the oral health is illustrated dramatically by observing changes in oral health after therapeutic radiation to the head and neck. After radiation, salivary glands become fibrotic and produce little or no saliva, leaving the patient with an extremely dry mouth, a condition termed xerostomia (xero, dry; stoma, mouth). Such patients may experience near-total destruction of the teeth in just a few months after radiation treatment.8,9 Salivary protective mechanisms that maintain the normal oral flora and tooth surface integrity include bacterial clearance, direct antibacterial activity, buffers, and remineralization.10

Table 2-3

Elements of Saliva that Control Plaque Biofilm Communities

Names Action Effects on Plaque Biofilm Community
Amylase Cleaves—1,4 glucoside bonds Increases availability of oligosaccharides
Lactoperoxidase Catalyzes hydrogen peroxide–mediated oxidation; adsorbs to hydroxyapatite in active form Lethal to many organisms: suppresses plaque formation on tooth surfaces
Lysozyme Lyses cells by degradation of cell walls, releasing peptidoglycans; binds to hydroxyapatite in active conformation Lethal to many organisms; peptidoglycans activate complement; suppresses plaque formation on tooth surfaces
Lipases Hydrolysis of triglycerides to free fatty acids and partial glycerides Free fatty acids inhibit attachment and growth of some organisms
Lactoferrin Ties up free iron Inhibits growth of some iron-dependent microbes
Secretory immunoglobulin A(IgA) (smaller amounts of IgM, IgG) Agglutination of bacteria inhibits bacterial enzymes Reduces numbers in saliva by precipitation; slows bacterial growth
Glycoproteins (mucins) Agglutination of bacteria Reduces numbers in saliva by precipitation


Table 2-4

Medications with Potential to Cause Hyposalivation or Dry Mouth (Xerostomia)

Action/Medication Group Medicaments

ANTICHOLINERGIC Tricyclic antidepressants

Muscarinic receptor antagonists Alpha-receptor antagonists Antipsychotics Antihistamines ANTICHOLINERGIC, DEHYDRATION Diuretics SYMPATHOMIMETIC Antihypertensive agents Appetite suppressants Decongestants Bronchodilators Skeletal muscle relaxants Antimigraine agents SYNERGISTIC MECHANISM Opioids, hypnotics UNKNOWN H2 antagonists, proton pump inhibitors Cytotoxic drugs Anti-HIV drugs, protease inhibitors


(Adapted from the Kois Center, Support Materials, Always Pages, http://koiscenter.com/store/supmatlist.aspx, accessed January 13, 2012.)

Bacterial Clearance

Secretions from various salivary glands pool in the mouth to form whole or mixed saliva. The amount of saliva secreted varies greatly over time. When secreted, saliva remains in the mouth for a short time before being swallowed. While in the mouth, saliva lubricates oral tissues and bathes teeth and the biofilm. The secretion rate of saliva may have a bearing on caries susceptibility and calculus formation. Adults produce 1-1.5 L of saliva a day, very little of which occurs during sleep. The flushing effect of this salivary flow is, by itself, adequate to remove virtually all microorganisms not adherent to an oral surface. The flushing is most effective during mastication or oral stimulation, both of which produce large volumes of saliva. Large volumes of saliva also can dilute and buffer biofilm acids.

Direct Antibacterial Activity

Salivary glands produce an impressive array of antimicrobial products (see Table 2-3). Lysozyme, lactoperoxidase, lactoferrin, and agglutinins possess antibacterial activity. These salivary proteins are not part of the immune system but are part of an overall protection scheme for mucous membranes that occurs in addition to immunologic control. These protective proteins are present continuously at relatively uniform levels, have a broad spectrum of activity, and do not possess the “memory” of immunologic mechanisms. The normal resident oral flora apparently has developed resistance to most of these antibacterial mechanisms.

Although the antibacterial proteins in saliva play an important role in the protection of soft tissue in the oral cavity from infection by pathogens, they have little effect on caries because similar levels of antibacterial proteins can be found in caries-active and caries-free individuals.11,12 It is suggested that caries susceptibility in healthy individuals is not related to saliva composition. Individuals with decreased salivary production (owing to illness, medication, or irradiation) may have significantly higher caries susceptibility (see Table 2-4).

Buffer Capacity

The volume and buffering capacity of saliva available to tooth surfaces have major roles in caries protection.13 The buffering capacity of saliva is determined primarily by the concentration of bicarbonate ion. Buffering capacity can be estimated by titration techniques and may be a useful method for assessment of saliva in caries-active patients. The benefit of the buffering is to reduce the potential for acid formation.

In addition to buffers, saliva contains molecules that contribute to increasing biofilm pH. These include urea and sialin, which is a tetrapeptide that contains lysine and arginine. Hydrolysis of either of these basic compounds results in production of ammonia, causing the pH to increase.

Because saliva is crucial in controlling the oral flora and the mineral content of teeth, salivary testing should be done on patients with high caries activity. A portion of the salivary sample also may be used for bacteriologic testing, as will be described later in this chapter.

Diet and Caries

High-frequency exposure of fermentable carbohydrates such as sucrose may be the most important factor in producing cariogenic biofilm and, ultimately, caries lesions. Frequent ingestion of fermentable carbohydrates begins a series of changes in the local tooth environment that promotes the growth of highly acidogenic bacteria and eventually leads to caries. In contrast, when ingestion of fermentable carbohydrates is severely restricted or absent, biofilm growth typically does not lead to caries. Dietary sucrose plays a leading role in the development of pathogenic biofilms and may be the most important factor in disruption of the normal healthy ecology of dental biofilm communities. Because the eventual metabolic product of cariogenic diet is acid, and the acid leads to the development of caries, the exposure to acidity from other sources (e.g., dried fruits, fruit drinks, or other acidic foods and drinks) also may result in caries. The dietary emphasis must include all intakes that result in acidity, not just sucrose.

Clinical Characteristics of the Caries Lesion

The caries lesion is the product of disequilibrium between the demineralization and remineralization processes discussed previously. When the tooth surface becomes cavitated, a more retentive surface area becomes available to the biofilm community. The cavitation of the tooth surface produces a synergistic acceleration of the growth of the cariogenic biofilm community and the expansion of the demineralization with ensuing expanded cavitation. This situation results in a rapid and progressive destruction of the tooth structure. When enamel caries penetrates to the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ), rapid lateral expansion of the caries lesion occurs because dentin is much less resistant to acid demineralization. This sheltered, highly acidic, and anaerobic environment provides an ideal niche for cariogenic bacteria.

Clinical Sites for Caries Initiation

The characteristics of a caries lesion vary with the nature of the surface on which the lesion develops. There are three distinctly different clinical sites for caries initiation: (1) developmental pits and fissures of enamel, which are the most susceptible sites; (2) smooth enamel surfaces that shelter cariogenic biofilm; and (3) the root surface (see Fig. 2-14). Each of these areas has distinct surface topography and environmental conditions. Consequently, each area has a distinct biofilm population. The diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of these different lesion types should take into account the different etiologic factors operating at each site.

Pits and Fissures

Bacteria rapidly colonize the pits and fissures of newly erupted teeth. The type and nature of the organisms prevalent in the oral cavity determine the type of organisms colonizing pits and fissures and are instrumental in determining the outcome of the colonization. Large variations exist in the microflora found in pits and fissures, suggesting that each site can be considered a separate ecologic system. Numerous gram-positive cocci, especially S. sanguis, are found in the pits and fissures of newly erupted teeth, whereas large numbers of MS usually are found in carious pits and fissures.

The shape of the pits and fissures contributes to their high susceptibility to caries. The long, narrow fissure prevents adequate biofilm removal (see Fig. 2-12). Considerable morphologic variation exists in these structures. Some pits and fissures end blindly, others open near the dentin, and others penetrate entirely through the enamel.

Pit-and-fissure caries expands as it penetrates into the enamel. The entry site may appear much smaller than the actual lesion, making clinical diagnosis difficult. Caries lesions of pits and fissures develop from attack on their walls (see Fig. 2-15, A through C). Progression of the dissolution of the walls of a pit-and-fissure lesion is similar in principle to that of the smooth-surface lesion because a wide area of surface attack extends inward, paralleling the enamel rods. A lesion originating in a pit or fissure affects a greater area of the DEJ than does a comparable smooth-surface lesion. In cross-section, the gross appearance of a pit-and-fissure lesion is an inverted “V” with a narrow entrance and a progressively wider area of involvement closer to the DEJ (see Fig. 2-15, D).

Smooth Enamel Surfaces

The smooth enamel surfaces of teeth present a less favorable site for cariogenic biofilm attachment. Cariogenic biofilm usually develops only on the smooth surfaces that are near the gingiva or are under proximal contacts. The proximal surfaces are particularly susceptible to caries because of the extra shelter provided to resident cariogenic biofilm owing to the proximal contact area immediately occlusal to it (Fig. 2-22). Lesions starting on smooth enamel surfaces have a broad area of origin and a conical, or pointed, extension toward the DEJ. The path of ingress of the lesion is roughly parallel to the long axis of the enamel rods in the region. A cross-section of the enamel portion of a smooth-surface lesion shows a V-shape, with a wide area of origin and the apex of the V directed toward the DEJ. After caries penetrates the DEJ, softening of dentin spreads rapidly laterally and pulpally (see Fig. 2-21).

Root Surfaces

The root surface is rougher than enamel and readily allows cariogenic biofilm formation in the absence of good oral hygiene. The cementum covering the root surface is extremely thin and provides little resistance to caries attack. In addition, the critical pH for dentin is higher than for enamel, so demineralization is likely to start even before the pH reaches the critical level for enamel (pH = 5.5). Root caries lesions have less well-defined margins, tend to be U-shaped in cross-section, and progress more rapidly because of the lack of protection from an enamel covering. In recent years, the prevalence of root caries has increased significantly because of the increasing number of older persons who retain more teeth, experience gingival recession, and usually have cariogenic biofilm on the exposed root surfaces.1518

Progression of Caries Lesions

The progression and morphology of the caries lesion vary, depending on the site of origin and the conditions in the mouth (see Figs. 2-14, 2-15, and 2-21). The time for progression from non-cavitated caries to clinical caries (cavitation) on smooth surfaces is estimated to be 18 months ± 6 months.19 Peak rates for the incidence of new lesions occur 3 years after the eruption of the tooth. Occlusal pit-and-fissure lesions develop in less time than smooth-surface caries. Poor oral hygiene and frequent exposures to sucrose-containing or acidic food can produce noncavitated (“white spot”) lesions (first clinical evidence of demineralization) in 3 weeks. Radiation-induced xerostomia (dry mouth) can lead to clinical caries development in 3 months from the onset of the radiation. Caries development in healthy individuals is usually slow compared with the rate possible in compromised persons.

Enamel Caries

An understanding of the enamel composition and histology is helpful to understand enamel caries histopathology (see Chapter 1 (Figs. 2-23 to 2-25). On clean, dry teeth, the earliest evidence of caries on the smooth enamel surface of a crown is a white spot (Fig. 2-26; see also Figs. 2-2 and 2-3). These lesions usually are observed on the facial and lingual surfaces of teeth. White spots are chalky white, opaque areas that are revealed only when the tooth surface is desiccated and are termed noncavitated enamel caries lesions. These areas of enamel lose their translucency because of the extensive subsurface porosity caused by demineralization. Care must be exercised in distinguishing white spots of noncavitated caries from developmental white spot hypocalcifications of enamel. Noncavitated (white spot) caries partially or totally disappears visually when the enamel is hydrated (wet), whereas hypocalcified enamel is affected less by drying and wetting (Table 2-5). Hypocalcified enamel does not represent a clinical problem except for its esthetically objectionable appearance. The surface texture of a non-cavitated lesion is unaltered and is undetectable by tactile examination with an explorer. A more advanced lesion develops a rough surface that is softer than the unaffected, normal enamel. Softened chalky enamel that can be chipped away with an explorer is a sign of active caries. Injudicious use of an explorer tip can cause actual cavitation in a previously noncavitated area, requiring, in most cases, restorative intervention. Similar noncavitated lesions occur on the proximal smooth surfaces, but usually are undetectable by visual or judicious tactile (explorer) examination. Noncavitated enamel lesions sometimes can be seen on radiographs as a faint radiolucency that is limited to the superficial enamel. When a proximal lesion is clearly visible radiographically, the lesion may have advanced significantly, and histologic alteration of the underlying dentin probably already has occurred, whether the lesion is cavitated or not (Fig. 2-27).

Table 2-5

Clinical Characteristics of Normal and Altered Enamel

  Hydrated Desiccated Surface Texture Surface Hardness
Normal enamel Translucent Translucent Smooth Hard
Hypocalcified enamel Opaque Opaque Smooth Hard
Noncavitated caries Translucent Opaque Smooth Softened
Active caries Opaque Opaque Cavitated Very soft
Inactive caries Opaque, dark Opaque, dark Roughened Hard


Fig. 2-25 A, Cross-section of small caries lesion in enamel examined in quinoline with polarized light (×100). Advancing front of lesion appears as a dark band below body of lesion. B, Same section after exposure to artificial calcifying solution examined in quinoline and polarized light. Dark zone (DZ) covers a much greater area after remineralization has occurred (×100). C, Schematic diagram of Figs. 2-25, A and B. Left side indicates small extent of zones 1 and 2 before remineralization. Small circles indicate relative sizes of pores in each zone. Right side indicates increase in zone 2, the dark zone, after remineralization. This micropore system must have been created where previously the pores were much larger. (Redrawn from Silverstone LM et al, editors: Dental caries, London and Basingstoke, 1981, Macmillan, Ltd., C was redrawn)

It has been shown experimentally and clinically that noncavitated caries of enamel can remineralize.2021 Table 2-5 and Table 2-6 list the characteristics of enamel at various stages of demineralization. Noncavitated enamel lesions retain most of the original crystalline framework of the enamel rods, and the etched crystallites serve as nucleating agents for remineralization. Calcium and phosphate ions from saliva can penetrate the enamel surface and precipitate on the highly reactive crystalline surfaces in the enamel lesion. The supersaturation of saliva with calcium and phosphate ions serves as the driving force for the remineralization process. Artificial and natural caries lesions of human enamel have been shown to regress to earlier histologic stages after exposure to conditions that promote remineralization. The presence of trace amounts of fluoride ions during this remineralization process greatly enhances the precipitation of calcium and phosphate, resulting in the remineralized enamel becoming more resistant to subsequent caries attack because of the incorporation of more acid-resistant fluorapatite (Fig. 2-28). Remineralized (arrested) lesions can be observed clinically as intact, but discolored, usually brown or black, spots (Fig. 2-29). The change in color is presumably caused by trapped organic debris and metallic ions within the enamel. These discolored, remineralized, arrested caries areas are intact and are more resistant to subsequent caries attack than the adjacent unaffected enamel. They should not be restored unless they are esthetically objectionable.

Table 2-6

Clinical Significance of Enamel Lesions

  Plaque Biofilm Enamel Structure Non-restorative, Therapeutic Treatment (e.g., remineralization, antimicrobial, pH control) Restorative Treatment
Normal enamel Normal Normal Not indicated Not indicated
Hypocalcified enamel Normal Abnormal, but not weakened Not indicated Only for esthetics
Noncavitated caries Cariogenic Porous, weakened Yes Not indicated
Active caries Cariogenic Cavitated, very weak Yes Yes
Inactive caries Normal Remineralized, strong Not indicated Only for esthetics


Cavitated enamel lesions can be initially detected as subtle breakdown of the enamel surface. These lesions are very sensitive to probing, and can be easily enlarged by using sharp explorers and excessive probing force. More advanced cavitated enamel lesions are more obviously detected as enamel breakdown. Although some cavitated enamel lesions can be arrested and may not progress to larger lesions, most cavitated caries lesions require restorative treatment.

Dentin Caries

An understanding of the dentin composition and histology is helpful to understand the histopathology of dentin caries (see Chapter 1 (Fig. 2-30). Progression of caries in dentin is different from progression in the overlying enamel because of the structural differences of dentin (Figs. 2-31 to 2-33; see also Fig. 2-30). Dentin contains much less mineral and possesses microscopic tubules that provide a pathway for the ingress of bacteria and egress of minerals. The DEJ has the least resistance to caries attack and allows rapid lateral spreading when caries has penetrated the enamel (see Figs. 2-15 and 2-21). Because of these characteristics, dentinal caries is V-shaped in cross-section with a wide base at the DEJ and the apex directed pulpally. Caries advances more rapidly in dentin than in enamel because dentin provides much less resistance to acid attack owing to less mineralized content. Caries produces a variety of responses in dentin, including pain, sensitivity, demineralization, and remineralization.

Fig. 2-30 Normal and carious dentin. A, Normal dentin has characteristic tubules that follow a wavy path from the external surface of dentin, below enamel or cementum, to the inner surface of dentin in the pulp tissue of the pulp chamber or pulp canal. Dentin is formed from the external surface and grows inward. As dentin grows, odontoblasts become increasingly compressed in the shrinking pulp chamber, and the number of associated tubules becomes more concentrated per unit area. The more recently formed dentin near the pulp (a) has large tubules with little or no peritubular dentin and calcified intertubular dentin filled with collagen fibers. Older dentin, closer to the external surface (b), is characterized by smaller, more widely separated tubules and a greater mineral content in intertubular dentin. The older dentin tubules are lined by a uniform layer of mineral termed peritubular dentin. These changes occur gradually from the inner surface to the external surface of the dentin. Horizontal lines indicate predentin; diagonal lines indicate increasing density of minerals; darker horizontal lines indicate densely mineralized dentin and increased thickness of peritubular dentin. The transition in mineral content is gradual, as indicated in Fig. 2-25. B, Carious dentin undergoes several changes. The most superficial infected zone of carious dentin (3) is characterized by bacteria filling the tubules and granular material in the intertubular space. The granular material contains very little mineral and lacks characteristic cross-banding of collagen. As bacteria invade dentinal tubules, />

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free dental videos. Join our Telegram channel

Jan 9, 2015 | Posted by in Operative Dentistry | Comments Off on 2: Dental Caries: Etiology, Clinical Characteristics, Risk Assessment, and Management

VIDEdental - Online dental courses

Get VIDEdental app for watching clinical videos