Reinforcement of resin based cement with titania nanotubes



One of the limitations of resin cements and flowable dental composites is their poor mechanical properties such as low flexural strength and fracture resistance under body conditions. The present study was performed to enhance the mechanical properties of commercial acrylic cement (CMW ® 1) by introducing novel nanostructured titania tubes (n-TiO 2 tubes) into the cement matrix, with the tubes acting as a reinforcing phase. The long term objective is to add these fillers as reinforcement to dental resin cements and flowable composites in combination with existing fillers.


The surface of the n-TiO 2 tubes was modified using a bi-functional monomer, methacrylic acid. The n-TiO 2 tube content of the cement was varied from 0 to 2 wt.%. The following cement properties were investigated: maximum polymerization temperature ( T max ), dough time ( t dough ), setting time ( t set ), complex viscosity-versus-time, radiopacity, fracture toughness ( K IC ), flexural strength (FS), flexural modulus (FM) and in vitro biocompatibility.


Based on the determined mechanical properties, the optimized composition was found at 1 wt.% n-TiO 2 tubes, which provided a significant increase in K IC (73%), FS (42%) and FM (56%). However the rheology, radiopacity and biocompatibility were not different from the control (CMW ® 1).


Enhanced interaction and strong adhesion between the functionalized n-TiO 2 tubes and polymer matrix allows external mechanical stress to be more effectively transferred through the filler-matrix interface. This novel filler in conjunction with the existing ones can be used to reinforce orthopedic and dental cements as well as flowable dental composites without altering the rheology, radiopacity and biocompatibility.


Polymer-based composites have been widely used in joint arthroplasty and dentistry as bone cements and dental restorative materials, respectively . Due to their potential for replacing the controversial dental amalgam, polymer-based dental restorative composites are increasingly becoming popular in posterior restorative application . Similarly, acrylic based cemented arthroplasties are drawing significant attention world-wide, because of the excellent primary fixation of the implant and fast recovery times for the patient . However, in-spite of having admirable records of performance, both of these composites suffer from poor mechanical performance which facilitates their failure due to bending induced breakage and fracture related cracking . Commercial bone cements contain barium sulfate (BaSO 4 ) or zirconium dioxide (ZrO 2 ) as X-ray contrast agents in particulate form, which are known to adversely affect the mechanical properties. Moreover, as there is no chemical reaction between the inorganic particles and the PMMA bone cements, it can be understood that the filler particles act like pores when a tensile stress is applied to the bone cement . Bone cement failure is responsible for a significant portion of the estimated 36,000 revision hip arthroplasties performed in 2003 in the United States, which is mainly attributed to a lack of sufficient mechanical properties of the commercial acrylic cement . Therefore, there is a sustained interest to improve the mechanical properties of polymer-based dental and orthopedic composites.

Fiber reinforcement is one of the most followed approaches to enhance the mechanical properties of polymer-based composites. Ceramic and metal fibers as well as whiskers were incorporated into orthopedic and dental resin matrices in different studies in order to improve the mechanical properties of the composites . These efforts have been less than ideally successful due to the large size of the fillers, poor filler-resin matrix bonding (and subsequent debonding), nonuniform filler material distribution, and the pores acting as stress concentration sites .

The introduction of nano-scale materials offers new promise for augmenting the mechanical properties of bone cements and dental composites due to their high surface area to volume ratio which enhances their interfacial interaction with the resin matrix . Marrs et al. reported the incorporation of multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT) as reinforcement into bone cement matrix. However, a slight increase in the mechanical properties was obtained due to the weak bonding between the non-functionalized MWCNT and the resin matrix. In addition, the biocompatibility of carbon nanotube reinforced bone cements seems to be challenging . Similarly, functionalized single-walled carbon nanotubes capable of establishing strong chemical bonds with the matrix polymer have been reported as reinforcing agents in the urethane dimethacrylate dental resin matrix with resulting higher flexural strength (FS) compared to the un-reinforced counterpart . However, addition of the carbon nanotubes may impose negative effects on the aesthetic requirements and biocompatibility of the dental composites. In other study, poor increase in the mechanical properties of bone cements was observed following the incorporation of calcium carbonate nanoparticles due to the agglomeration of nanoparticles and lack of adhesion between the nanoparticles and the resin matrix .

In a previously published work, we examined nanostructured functionalized titania fibers to augment a poly (methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) matrix, which provided significantly enhanced dynamic mechanical properties . Nanotubes, like nanofibers, have a high aspect ratio and a high surface area to volume ratio which may lead to significantly enhanced physical and mechanical properties . Moreover, the hollow structure of the nanotube provides additional interlocking with the matrix through both the interior and exterior surfaces of the tubes. Although titania is an established biocompatible material , nanomaterials are well known to exhibit completely different characteristics at their nanodimensions, often being more toxic. This is attributed to their larger surface area, enhanced chemical reactivity, and easier penetration into cells . Hence, the polymer matrix reinforced with n-TiO 2 tubes needs to be evaluated in terms of cell adhesion, proliferation and cytotoxicity.

In the present study, we have studied the inclusion of n-TiO 2 tubes in an acrylic polymer matrix. We have selected a commercial PMMA bone cement (CMW ® 1) as the control and incorporated the n-TiO 2 tubes with a loading of 0.5, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 wt.% and investigated the following properties of the resulting nanocomposites: complex viscosity-versus-time, maximum polymerization temperature, dough time, setting time, radiopacity, fracture toughness, flexural strength and flexural modulus. In order to obtain maximum enhancement of the mechanical properties, we have functionalized the n-TiO 2 tubes in an attempt to make the nanotubes more compatible with the matrix according to our previously described technique . The in vitro biocompatibility of the cement reinforced with n-TiO 2 tube was also investigated in this work using primary osteoblasts obtained from rat calvarias. We should note that PMMA bone cement was used as the model system in this study to investigate the potential of the n-TiO 2 tubes in strengthening low filled resin composites.

The hypothesis of this study is that functionalized n-TiO 2 tubes added to commercial resin cement will significantly enhance its mechanical properties without altering its rheology, radiopacity and biocompatibility.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Nov 30, 2017 | Posted by in Dental Materials | Comments Off on Reinforcement of resin based cement with titania nanotubes
Premium Wordpress Themes by UFO Themes